Tony Award winner Laura Benanti and Dancing with the Stars champion Derek Hough took a break from high-kicking with the world famous Rockettes in Radio City Music Hall’s New York Spring Spectacular to sit down with The Today Show’s Matt Lauer and Savannah Guthrie on March 20. The new show is truly a spectacular, from raining on stage to countless voice cameos to Benanti dancing! “I’m pretending to dance,” the Broadway alum joked. “It’s unbelievable…slash terrifying!” Check out the interview—plus a performance from the Rockettes—below!